Comparison of the Effectiveness of Cognitive-Behavioral and Emotion- Focused Couple Therapies on Marital Intimacy of Couples

Document Type: Original Article

Authors

1 Department of Counseling, Khuzestan Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ahvaz, Iran

2 Department of Counseling, Ahvaz Branch, Islamic Azad University, Ahvaz, Iran

Abstract

Abstract

Introduction: Intimacy has a fundamental importance in the survival of couples' relationships and its rate has a profound effect on marital happiness. The main objective of the present research was to investigate the effectiveness of cognitive-behavioral couple therapy as well as emotion-focused couple therapy on marital intimacy of couples referring to counseling centers in the city of Zabol, Iran.
Method: The current research was a quasi-experimental study with a randomized placement of subjects. The plan of the pre-test and post-test groups as well as control group with two experimental categories were used in this research to test the hypotheses. The statistical population included all couples referring to Zabol counseling centers during 2017-2018. The sample consisted of 24 couples (48 individuals) who were selected through targeted sampling and were randomly divided into three groups (each group with 8 pairs), namely, two experimental groups (cognitive-behavioral couple therapy and emotion-focused couple therapy) and a control group. The data were collected by questionnaire of Bagarozzi intimacy. Then, the collected data were analyzed according to covariance analysis (one way and multivariate method).
Results: According to the findings, both types of cognitive-behavioral couple therapy as well as emotion-focused couple therapy were effective in increasing marital intimacy. Also, both types of couple therapy were effective in promoting marital performance.
Conclusion: To conclude, the effect of cognitive-behavioral couple therapy and emotion-focused couple therapy is different with each other in improving marital performance and marital intimacy between couples.

Keywords


References
1.   Edalati A, Redzuan M. Perception of women towards family values and their marital satisfaction. Journal of American Science. 2010;6(4):132-7.
2.   Isanejad O, Amani A, Azizi A, Azimifar S. The relationship between personality factors, self-control and marital coping strategies with marital conflict. International Journal of Behavioral Sciences. 2016;9(4):19-25.
3.   Esmailbeigi Z, GHolamrezaie H. Intimacy miracle, key to life and successful relationship. Tehran naslenowandish; 2013.
4.   Bagarozzi DA. Enhancing Intimacy in Marriage A Clinician's Guide. New York: Routledge; 2001.
5.   Constant E, Vallet F, Nandrino J-L, Christophe V. Personal assessment of intimacy in relationships: Validity and measurement invariance across gender. Revue Européenne de Psychologie Appliquée/European Review of Applied Psychology. 2016;66(3):109-16.
6.   Schaefer MT, Olson DH. Assessing intimacy: The PAIR inventory. Journal of marital and family therapy. 1981;7(1):47-60.
7.   Fife ST, Weeks GR. Barriers to recovering intimacy. Recovering intimacy in love relationships: A clinician’s guide. 2010:157-79.
8.   Hatfield E, Bensman L, Rapson RL. Love and intimacy, Equity. In: Ramachandan VS, editor. Encyclopedia of Human Behavior. 2 ed. NewYork: Academic press; 2012. p. 550-6.
9.   Johnson S. The practice of emotionally focused couples therapy. New York: Brunner Roudedge. 2004.
10. Akhavan-Bitaghsir Z, Sanaee-Zaker B, Navabinejad S, Farzad VA. The Effectiveness of Emotional Focused Couple Therapy on Satisfaction and Marital Adjustment in Couples.  International Journal of Behavioral Sciences. 2016;14(3):324-30.
11. Soltani M, Shaeiri M.R. Roshan R. The effects of emotional focused THERAPY on increasing the marriage suitability of barren couples, International Journal of Behavioral Sciences, Vol 6, No.4 , Winter 2013. Page:383-389.
12. Dattilio FM. Introduction to the special section: The role of cognitive–behavioral interventions in couple and family therapy. Journal of marital and family therapy. 2005;31(1):7-13.
13.  Patterson T. Cognitive Behavioral Couple Therapy, In Harway M, Editor: Hand book of Couple Therapy. New Jersey: Wiley. 2005;119-140.
14.  Baucom DH, Sayers SL. Sher TG. Supplementing behavior marital therapy with cognitive restructuring and emotional expressiveness training: An outcome investigation. Journal of consulting and clinical psychology. 1990;58:636-645.
15.  Dandeneav M. Facilitating intimacy: A comparative outcome study of emotionally foc5sed and cognitive intervention. ProQuest. Dissertation & Theses, 1990.
16.  Amani R, Majzoobi MR. Comparing Effectiveness of Emotional Focused, Cognitive Behavioral and Cognitive Behavior Emotional Couple Therapy on the Change Process of Spouses' Marital Satisfaction and Women Depression. Journal of Family Counseling and Psychotherapy. 2013;3(3):439-469.
17.  Davoudvandi M, Navabinejad S, Farzad V. The Effectiveness of Emotionally Focused Couple Therapy in Improving Marital Adjustment and Couples’ Intimacy. QJFR. 2018;15(1):39-56.
18.  Pirfalak M, Sodani M, shafiabadi A. The Efficacy of Group Cognitive-Behavioral Couple’s Therapy (GCBCT) on the Decrease of Couple Burnout. Journal of Family Counseling & Psychotherapy. 2014;4(2):185-339. 
19.  Etemadi A, Navabi Nejad Sh, Ahmadi A, Farzad WA. Study of the effect of couple therapy in the method of immunotherapy on the increase of couples' intimacy referring to counseling centers in Tehran. Refreshments and Consulting Research. 2006;5(19):22-9.
20.  Khamse A, Hoseyniyan S. Gender Differences between Intimacy Dimensions of Married College Students. Quarterly Journal of Women's Studies Sociological and Psychological. 2008;6(1):52-35
21.  Johnson SM, Greenberg LS. Emotionally  focused Couples Therapy, Creating  Connection. New York: Brunner/Mazel. 1985.
22.  Baucom DH, Shoham V. Musere KT, Daiuto AD, Stickle TR. Empricially supported couples and family therapies for adult problems. Journal of consulting and clinical psychology. 1998;66:53-88.
23.  Johnson SM, Talitman E. Predicators of success in emotionally focused couples Therapy: status and challenges. Journal of Clinical Pcychology: Science and Practice. 1997;6:67-79.
24.  Snyder DK, Willis RM, Grady Fietcher A. Long-term effectiveness of behavior versus insightoriented marital therapy: A 4- year follow up study. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. 1991;59:138-141.
25.  Dattilio FM. HomworkAssignmentsin Couple and Family Therapy. Journal of Clinical psychology. 2002;58(5):570-583.
26.  Northey WF. Characteristics and Clinical practices of Marriage and Family Therapists.A national survey. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy. 2002;28:487-494.