Comparing the Effectiveness of Olson Circumplex Model and Walsh Integrated Approach on Marital Resilience and Conflicts of Couple

Authors

Abstract

The present study was conducted aiming at comparing the effectiveness of Olson Circumplex Model and Walsh Integrated Approach on marital resiliency and conflicts of couple. In this experimental procedure, from among all the couples who had referred to the counseling offices in district 3 of Tehran city in 2014 due to marital conflicts, 30 coupes eligible for the conditions intended by researcher were selected as samples through random replacement sampling method and were randomly placed in three groups, namely two test groups and one witness group. Then, both test groups were influenced by independent variables(Olson model and Walsh approach)within 8 sessions each for 90-120 minutes. Instruments used in this study included resilience scale(CD-RISC)and Marital Conflicts Questionnaire (MCQ)which were used within three stages, namely pretest, posttest and 3-month follow-up. Finally, the collected data was analyzed by using variance analysis test with repeated measurement. Results indicated a significant difference between average marks of test and control groups in marital resilience and conflicts as compared to control group; i.e., training of Olson Circumplex Model and Walsh Integrated Approach increased marital resilience and decreased marital conflicts between the couple and this is a durable effect over time. No significant difference was found in resilience between the two groups in comparing the effectiveness of two approaches which means that both studied methods had almost the same therapeutic effect on the couple's resilience. But a significant different difference was found between the two groups in marital conflicts. Averages showed that Olson Circumplex Model enjoyed a higher effectiveness in reducing marital conflicts between the couples as compared to Walsh Integrated Approach.

  1. Walsh,F.(2011). Strengthen the resilience of the family (passage the hardships of life). Translators: Dehghani, M., Khaje Rasouli, M., Mohammadi S., and Abbasi, M. Tehran: Danjeh Publishers. [Persian]
  2. Walsh, F.(2006). Strengthening family resilience. New York: Guilford Press
  3. Neff,L.A., Bradly, E.F.(2011). Stress resilience in early marriage: can practice make perfect? Journal of Personality & social psychology, 98, 1-18.
  4. Olson, D.H.(2009). Face IV and the Ciromplex model: validation study. Journal of marital and family therapy, dio: 10.1111/j.1752-0606. 2009.00175.x.
  5. Vandeleur, C.L., Jeanpretre, N., Perrez, M., & Schoebi, D.(2009). Cohesion, Satisfaction eith Family Bonds, and Emotional Well-Being in Families with Adolescents. Journal of Marriage and Family, 71, 1205-1219.
  6. Carlson J, Sperry L, Lewis J A. Family Therapy/Ensuring Treatment Efficacy. Translated be Shokouh Navabi Nejad. 2009; Tehran: Parents- Teachers Association of the Islamic Republic of Iran Publishers. [Persian]